Winning Cookie Swap Recipe: Chocolate & Peanut Butter Chip Pretzel Cookies {with printable recipe card} | i should be mopping the floor
Homepage Projects and Crafts Free Fonts Free Printables and SVG Files Printables Journals and Planners Facebook Covers and Device Wallpapers Summer Projects and Printables

Winning Cookie Swap Recipe: Chocolate & Peanut Butter Chip Pretzel Cookies {with printable recipe card}

Last night we had our monthly Hot Glue Hotties get together {to find out more about my craft group, click here}. Instead of crafting, we did a super fun cookie swap. We each brought one type of cookie, but left with a bucket-full of 13 cookie varieties {and one cupcake, too}!

I'll be posting later this week with our cookie swap details, including recipes for all 13 cookies as well as our appetizers for that night.

But for now, I wanted to share with you the winning recipe of the night.
We each tasted all of the cookies and then voted on our favorite
{this is a tasting plate pictured, right? Diet=Blown}.

Our cookie winner was from Hot Glue Hottie Suzanne.
Suzanne brought Chocolate & Peanut Butter Chip Pretzel Cookies.
The combination of sweet and savory was remarkable. And the pretzel bits added such a fantastic texture to an already beautiful cookie. Suzanne will hold the Cookie Queen title and reserve all bragging rights for an entire year...until we battle in December 2013 with more cookie craziness.

One requirement for the evening was to {in addition to your cookies} bring a new cookie cutter. We placed all of the cutters in a bag and awarded our winner with it.
{For those of you non-Texans, that's a straight-up Longhorn cookie cutter...Hook 'Em Horns}.

 To download this printable recipe card {in both 4x6 and 3x5 sizes}, click on the above image.

Suzanne found the original recipe for this winning cookie over at
Sugar Cooking.

{i linky-party here}


  1. I would love to have been there with all those yummy cookies and such ! Looks like fun was had by all.

  2. Oh man..yes I do need to make those bad boys!! Maybe they will win at my cookie exchange party I am attending on Sat. that would be funny don't ya think!

  3. I love the idea of bringing a cookie cutter along to a cookie swap!! I have one this Thursday night and am on my third try of testing out suitable cookies. Somehow as a food blogger there is more pressure to bring a great cookie!!

  4. This sounds like so much fun! And that plate is making me hungry and crave cookies even though it is only 9.30am! Oh well! Looks like you had a fabulous night...and the winning cookie sounds yummy! New follower :)

  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

  6. That sounds like a lot of fun, and yummy cookies. I love the cookie cutter prize idea.

  7. Can't wait to try these. They look yummy. Love you recipe card.I would love for you to visit me at
    Merry Christmas,
    Wanda Ann

  8. I must try this winning recipe! Do you offer just the recipe card on your blog? It would be perfect for holiday recipes.